Being convicted of a crime in Michigan, or a federal crime in the U.S., can be life-altering, with the potential for long prison sentences, hefty fines, and a ruined reputation. It can be even more devastating if there were errors in your trial or if your rights were breached during the criminal defense process that led to your conviction. A skilled Michigan criminal appeals lawyer from SBBL Law can help you navigate the appeals process successfully to bring your case to justice.
At SBBL Law, our firm was founded by former federal prosecutors, FBI Special Agents, and Army JAG officers who understand what it takes to put a criminal case together, and our attorneys are keenly aware of what mistakes and trial errors by police and prosecutors can lead to a strong appeal.
The post-conviction criminal appellate process is triggered when an individual convicted of a crime tries to get their sentence or conviction reviewed by a higher court. An appeal is a request and challenge made to a higher court to review decisions and procedures that occurred in the lower court, especially during trials and sentencing hearings. During the appeal process, higher courts will decide whether any errors made impacted the final outcome of a lower court proceeding or trial and, if so, what remedy is appropriate to fix the issue.
An interlocutory criminal appeal is a court appeal of a non-final ruling made by the trial court during the pendency of a criminal case. In Michigan, for example, defendants can ask the court of appeals to review a trial court decision to deny a defense motion, such as a motion to suppress evidence, and the court of appeals may review the appeal before trial. These types of appeals are “by application” and not “by right,” meaning that a defendant must ask and receive permission from the court of appeals to file an interlocutory appeal. The court of appeals can decline to review an interlocutory appeal.
There are two main types of post-conviction appeals in Michigan: appeal by application for leave and appeal by right. Each category requires different procedures and has varied associated goals. An appeal by right is typically an option available to individuals who were convicted in a trial. Such cases give a party an automatic right to file an appeal.
On the other hand, an appeal by application for leave requires that the appealing party seek permission from the appellate court to file an appeal. This means the appellate court will have a discretionary review, meaning that they can decide whether or not to review the case. The appeal by application for leave route is typically taken by those where the automatic right to appeal is not available, such as after convictions by plea or in the middle of trial proceedings via an interlocutory appeal.
In Michigan, defendants may file a “6.500 Motion” in some circumstances, such as after they have exhausted all their state appeal remedies, if they missed appeal deadlines, or if they cannot lawfully appeal in federal court. The rules for a 6.500 motion are complex. With few exceptions, a defendant is limited to filing only one 6.500 motion, so it is imperative to hire an experienced attorney. In a 6.500 motion, you can raise issues such as ineffective assistance of counsel, newly discovered evidence, or subsequent changes in the law that would have changed the outcome of your case.
The appellate process is complex, so it is imperative to hire an experienced criminal appellate attorney to navigate the process, identify legal issues, and argue those issues in the appropriate higher court. An experienced attorney, such as the appellate team at SBBL Law, can help you work through the following process, protecting your rights and interests:
By working with an experienced criminal appeals lawyer, you can successfully navigate the appeals process, ensuring key documents are submitted in detail and on time. By launching a strong appeals argument, you can work to push for more optimal outcomes in your criminal defense case.
The Michigan Supreme Court is the highest court in Michigan, and it is the state’s court of last resort, which means it has final appellate authority in the State of Michigan. The Michigan Supreme Court consists of seven elected justices, each of whom serves an 8-year term before having to be re-elected. The only court that is higher than the Michigan State Supreme Court is the United States Supreme Court. The Michigan Supreme Court functions as a general overseer of the overall court system in Michigan and creates and implements practices and procedures for the state court system.
The Michigan Supreme Court only considers certain types of appeals. For that reason, all appeals filed in the Michigan Supreme Court must begin with an application for leave to appeal. The Michigan Supreme Court has the discretion either to grant or deny permission to appeal to that Court. Appeals to the Michigan Supreme Court usually challenge decisions made by the Michigan Court of Appeals.
If the Michigan Supreme Court accepts an appeal for review, it may hear oral argument by the parties and will issue a written opinion. A decision by the Michigan Supreme Court requires a majority vote of the judges. In some cases, the Michigan Supreme Court will order the parties to submit supplemental briefs so that the justices can better understand the case and the applicable law, but the parties cannot present new evidence not already in the official record from the trial court.
The appeals process can also look different depending on whether the case is at the state or federal level, and having an experienced appellate attorney who can determine the correct court for your case is important. The Michigan State Court of Appeals handles appeals from state trial courts, while the Federal Circuit Court of Appeals oversees federal district courts.
If your conviction was in a state court in Michigan, you will typically begin with appealing to a higher court within the state. However, if your conviction was on the federal level, a criminal defense lawyer can assist you with filing a federal appeal.
Likewise, if the issues with your trial are related to noncompliance with the state’s constitution or laws, a state appeal would be relevant for your case. If you have exhausted your state appeals and are incarcerated, you can pursue a habeas corpus motion in federal court if you have an argument that you are being held in custody unlawfully.
A Michigan criminal appeals lawyer can support you in a variety of ways to improve your chances of a successful appeal. Attorneys at SBBL Law have extensive experience as both trial attorneys and appellate attorneys and possess the knowledge and skill to identify and argue the issues necessary for appellate success. We can leverage these skills to help you in the following ways:
The criminal appeals process is full of uncertainty and complexity, so it is important to work with a legal team that offers enhanced client communication and support. Throughout the appeals process, our legal team will actively keep in touch with you to inform you of your case status and any relevant changes.
Based on the details of your case, the diligent appellate team at SBBL Law will work to help you design and implement a strategic appeal plan. Our team has a successful track record of handling a variety of appellate cases. Let us help you make your case right by initiating and navigating the appeals process.
The appeals process gives the defendant a chance to insist on their right to a fair and legal trial, even when the trial court got it wrong. Serving time for a crime you did not commit has a devastating cost that cannot be tangibly calculated. Costs for the appeals process can include:
In some cases, the defendant may be able to file for court fees to be waived. It is important to work with an appellate lawyer who is transparent and upfront about the cost of their services and other costs associated with the appeals process.
If you received an unjust sentence due to rights violations or legal errors or were convicted for a crime you did not commit, the experienced team at SBBL Law is here to help you navigate the appeals process. The justice system does make mistakes, which is why the appellate court is available to review cases. We can help you make it right.
Contact us today to discuss the details of your situation, and we can help you move forward.
Our criminal lawyers represent clients in nationwide federal criminal cases and Title IX investigations, and we regularly appear in courts throughout Michigan:
If you or someone you know is looking for a criminal defense attorney, call now for a free consultation (616) 458-5500 or (231) 924-8700 or connect with us online.
60 MONROE CENTER ST NW #500
GRAND RAPIDS, MI 49503
28 W. MAIN STREET
FREMONT, MI 49412